The Fish Store
 (631) 472-3018
836 Montauk Highway
Bayport New York, 11705

Dinner Menu

Market & Restaurant

All Dinners Served With Cole Slaw, Tartar Sauce, Lemon

Also Your Choice Of Fries, Rice, Or Baked Potato.

All Product Fried Is In 0 % Trans Fat Vegetable Oil.

Fried Dinners

Crab Cakes(Old Bay)-$8.99

Fish Cakes-$8.99

Flounder Fil-12.99

Stuffed Flounder Fil-$15.99
Spinach Stuffed Flounder Fil-$15.99

Bay Scallops-$11.99

Sea Scallops-$15.99



Clam Strips-$8.99





Cajun Catfish-$12.99

Chicken Fingers-$9.99

Buffalo Shrimp-$13.99

Soft Shell Crabs-1 pc $13.99 -2 pcs. $19.99
Fish and Chips-$11.99

Fried Combo Dinners

Fisherman's Platter-$14.99

Shrimp, Oysters, Bay Scallops, Clam Strips, & Flounder

Hat Trick-$13.99

Shrimp, Bay Scallops, & Flounder
(Broiled $1.00 extra)

Shellfish Medley-$13.99

Shrimp. Clam Strips, & Bay Scallops

Bucket Of Fish-$16.99

Choice of Three (with Fries, cole slaw, tartar, and cocktail sauce)

Cod-Haddock-Catfish-Cajun Catfish-Fish Cakes-Clam Strips-Buffalo Shrimp

Bucket Of Mussels-$14.99

3 Lbs. Served in a White Wine Garlic Sauce Or Red Sauce

Bucket Of Steamers-$18.99
3 Lbs. Seved in a White Wine Garlic Sauce

Sautéed Dinners

Maryland Style Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes (Real Blue Claw Meat)-$11.99

Soft Shell Crabs Sautéed With Wine & Seasoning-1pc. $13.99 -2pcs.$19.99

Lobster Roll
Real Lobster Salad on a toasted New England Bun
Single: $13.99
Dinner: $16.99

Broiled/Grilled Dinners



Salmon Fillet-$13.99

Wild Salmon-$15.99


Flounder Fillet-(Broiled Only)-$13.99

Stuffed Flounder with Seafood Stuffing or with Spinach & Feta Cheese-(Broiled Only)-$15.99

Bay Scallops-(Broiled Only)-$12.99

Sea Scallops-$16.99


Stuffed Shrimp-(Broiled Only)-$12.99

Shrimp Scampi-(Broiled Only)-$13.99

Red Snapper-$12.99




Chilean Sea Bass-$16.99


Cajun Catfish-$12.99

Orange Roughy-$13.99


All Broiled Dinners are Cooked With Butter, Lemon, & White Wine.
 Try One of our Marinades for 1.50 Extra. 
Lemon Butter Dill, House Marinade, Mom's Marinade, Lemon Butter Herb, Ginger
Teriyaki, Cajun, Caribbean, Honey Horseradish Mustard, Or Blackening.

Side Orders

French Fries Large-$2.99

French Fries Jumbo-$4.99

Curly Fries-$3.99

Sweet Potato Fries-$3.99
Baked Potato-$1.99
Mashed Potatoes-$2.99
Creamed Spinach and Feta-$4.99
Calamari (Squid)-$8.99

Mozzarella Sticks-$5.99

Onion Rings-$3.99

Zucchini Sticks-$3.99

Linguine w/Marinara-$4.99

Veggie of the day-$5.99

Stuffed Clams (3pcs)-$3.00

Stuffed Crab (1pc)-$2.50

Stuffed Mushrooms-$6.99

Clam Strips-$5.99
Yellow Rice-$1.99

Crab Cakes (4pcs)-$6.99
House Salad - $5.99
Shrimp Cocktail-$3.99

Buffalo Shrimp-$9.99

On the Half Shell

1/2 Dozen Little or Top Necks on 1/2 shell-$6.00

1 Dozen Little or Top Necks on 1/2 shell-$12.00

1 Dozen Steamed Little or Top Necks-$12.00

1/2 Dozen Oysters on 1/2 shell-$7.50

1 Dozen Oysters on 1/2 shell-$15.00

Whole Lobster Dinners

 1 1/4 lb-$24.99

1 1/2- 1 3/4 lb-$29.99

 2 lb-$39.99

 Served with  Cole Slaw, Lemon,  Butter, & Choice of Fries, Rice or Baked Potato.

Lobster Tail Dinners

Choice of One Tail or Two Tails. 

1 6oz Tail Dinner -$21.99------Twin.-$35.99

1 8oz Tail Dinner-$24.99-------Twin.-$41.99
1 10-12oz Tail Dinner-$29.99--------Twin,-$54.99

Served with  Cole Slaw, Lemon,  Butter, & Choice of Fries, Rice or Baked Potato.

Crab Leg Dinners

King Crab Legs (1 lb)-----------$41.99

Snow Crab Legs(1 lb)----------------$26.99

Served with  Cole Slaw, Lemon,  Butter, & Choice of Fries, Rice or Baked Potato.

Pasta Dinners Over Linguine

Clam Sauce (Red or White)-$13.99

Mussels Marinara (Red) or in White Garlic Sauce-$12.99

Shrimp Parmigiana-$16.99

Linguine Shrimp Scampi-$15.99

Shellfish Marinara (Red Sauce) or in a White Garlic Sauce-$15.99

Chicken Parmigiana-$15.99

Crispy Calamari Delight-$15.99

Served on a roll.  (Italian Bread 1.00 extra)
Comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, cole slaw, and fries.
Flounder Fil-----$10.99
Crab Cake (Old Bay)-----$9.99
Soft Shell Crab (seasonal)-----$14.99

Soup By The Cup Or Pint

Lobster Bisque-Cup $3.50 Pint $7.00

Seafood Bisque-Cup $3.50 Pint $7.00

New England Clam Chowder-Cup $3.50 Pint $7.00

Manhattan Clam Chowder-Cup $3.50 Pint $7.00

Ask About Our Weekly Dinner Specials When You Call In.

Contact Information


First Name:
Last Name:
Address Street 1:
Address Street 2:
Zip Code: (5 digits)
Daytime Phone:
Evening Phone: