tHE FISH STORE

tHE FISH STOREtHE FISH STOREtHE FISH STORE
  • Home/Contact Page
  • Up Coming/Current Events
  • RESTAURANT LUNCH MENU
  • Restaurant
  • Lunch/Take Out
  • Take Out Dinners
  • Sushi Menu
  • Fresh Fish
  • Catering Menu
  • Platters/Bakes
  • Group Tours/Other Service
  • Coupons
  • APPAREL
  • Gallery
  • More
    • Home/Contact Page
    • Up Coming/Current Events
    • RESTAURANT LUNCH MENU
    • Restaurant
    • Lunch/Take Out
    • Take Out Dinners
    • Sushi Menu
    • Fresh Fish
    • Catering Menu
    • Platters/Bakes
    • Group Tours/Other Service
    • Coupons
    • APPAREL
    • Gallery

tHE FISH STORE

tHE FISH STOREtHE FISH STOREtHE FISH STORE
  • Home/Contact Page
  • Up Coming/Current Events
  • RESTAURANT LUNCH MENU
  • Restaurant
  • Lunch/Take Out
  • Take Out Dinners
  • Sushi Menu
  • Fresh Fish
  • Catering Menu
  • Platters/Bakes
  • Group Tours/Other Service
  • Coupons
  • APPAREL
  • Gallery

aPPETIZERS

Maryland Crab Cake Appetizer

Clams on the Half Shell ........................................................................½ Doz. - 7.99 1 Doz. - 14.99  

South Shore Little or Top Neck Clams chilled and served with  cocktail sauce and lemon   

Oysters on the Half Shell  .....................................................................½ Doz. - 8.99 1 Doz. - 16.99  

Freshly shucked local oysters served with cocktail sauce  and lemon  Calamari................................................................................................................11.99  

Danielle’s choice crisp and tender deep fried calamari,  served with marinara sauce  

Baked Clams......................................................................................................11.99  

Long Island chopped clams and bread crumb seasoning,  served with lemon  

Maryland Crab Cakes................................................................................11.99  

Sautéed in a scallion sherry wine sauce overflowing  with crabmeat  

Oysters Rockefeller.......................................................................................12.99  

North shore oysters shucked and covered in a bacon,  spinach and feta mix then broiled to perfection  

Shrimp Cocktail...............................................................................................11.99  

Snap into plump, ice cold shrimp, served with homemade  cocktail sauce and lemon  

Coconut Shrimp..............................................................................................13.99  

Big Mama’s hand breaded secret recipe shrimp, served  with a coconut dipping sauce   

Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops...........................................................13.99  

Montauk caught dry sea scallops wrapped in bacon and  drizzled with honey horseradish mustard  

Shrimp Quesadilla........................................................................................13.99  

Stuffed with shrimp, tomato, cheddar and mozzarella  cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream  Clam Strips.........................................................................................................9.99  

Delicious breaded clam strips, deep fried and  served with homemade tartar sauce 

Clams Casino...................................................................................................12.99  

Long Island south shore clams freshly shucked then  cooked in our homemade bacon casino butter and  finished under the broiler.  

Stuffed Crabs...................................................................................................11.99  

Crab shells stuffed with shrimp, bay scallops &  crabmeat in a creamy au gratin. 

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms.............................................................11.99 

Topped with butter and mozzarella and packed  with seafood stuffing. 

Buffalo Shrimp...............................................................................................13.99 

Spicy hot hand-breaded shrimp fried and served  with bleu cheese. 

Prince Edward Island Mussels..........................................................12.99 

Steamed in a garlic wine sauce or marinara sauce. 

L.I. South Shore Clams.............................................................................12.99  

Steamed in a garlic wine sauce or marinara sauce. 

L.I. North Shore Steamers.....................................................................14.99  

Hand caught L.I. North Shore steamers in a butter  garlic wine sauce. 

Mozzarella Sticks..........................................................................................9.99 

Deep fried and served with homemade marinara  sauce. 

Zucchini Sticks................................................................................................9.99 

Deep fried and served with homemade marinara sauce. 

Loaded Potato with Shrimp................................................................10.99 

Stuffed with cheddar, mozzarella, bacon, scallions and shrimp. 

Seafood Chili....................................................................................................12.99 

Mama’s famous loaded with scallops, swordfish, tuna, tomato  sauce, beans, onions, pepper & spices. 

Cheese Nachos.............................................................................................10.99 

Shrimp Nachos..............................................................................................13.99 

Seafood Chili Nachos...............................................................................15.99 

Buffalo Wings.................................................................................................11.99 

Your choice of sweet or hot, Thai chili or teryaki.  


Cold Seafood Sampler............................................................................23.99

Includes 6 Little or Top Necks on the 1/2 shell, 6 Oysters on the 1/2 shell and 7 Shrimp Cocktail.

TFS Fried Combo Platter......................................................................21.99

Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, and Inion Rings.

Hot Seafood Sampler..............................................................................18.99

Includes Crab Cake Sliders, Calamari, Stuffed Clams and Potato Skins.

The Blue Point Combo............................................................................15.99

8 Blue Point Clams on the 1/2 shell & a 16oz Blue Point Beer on Tap 

SOUPS AND SALAD


Salads 

Caprese Salad................................................................................................14.99 

Seth’s favorite served with fresh mozzarella,  tomato, and homemade balsamic reduction  served over a bed of greens. 

TFS Salad...........................................................................................................14.99 

Served with craisins, crumbled feta cheese, glazed walnuts and  house dressing. 

Caesar Salad..................................................................................................13.99 

Served with croutons and Parmesan cheese. 

Garden Salad.................................................................................................11.99 

Served with tomato, cucumber, red onion and your choice  of dressing. 

Add 6oz’s of your favorite fish or chicken to any salad from our  grilled section... 5.99 extra 

Add fresh avocado...1.99 extra


Homemade Soups 

Soup Du Jour “Ask your Server”....................................................7.99 

Something new and tasty every day 

Manhattan Clam Chowder .................................................................7.99 

Classic tomato and vegetable bursting with flavor 

New England Clam Chowder ...........................................................7.99 

White and creamy, full of Long Island Clams and potatoes. 

Bread Bowl Add 2.99 

Seafood Bisque ............................................................................................7.99 

Pink, rich, and creamy, combined with varieties of fresh seafood. 

Bread Bowl Add 2.99 

Lobster Bisque .............................................................................................7.99 

Made from true Lobster stock and Lobster meat  with a creamy velvety flavor. 

Bread Bowl Add 2.99

fISH STORE FAVORITES

Fish Store Favorites 

Favorites are served with your choice of  the soup of the day or house salad. 


Poached Salmon ........................................................................................24.99 

Fresh Atlantic farm-raised salmon lightly seasoned and  poached served over mixed vegetables and topped with  our homemade Honey Horseradish Mustard. 

Wild Salmon - Add 4.99 

Flounder Francese ...................................................................................25.99 

Hand-cut Montauk flounder, pan-seared and  finished in a francese sauce served over rice.  Mango Peach  Swordfish or Salmon .......................................25.99 

Grilled and served over rice and smothered in a mango  peach sauce. 

Scampi Encrusted Sea Scallops ..................................................27.99 

Long Island Dry Ocean Sea Scallops pan seared and  encrusted with our own scampi sauce resting over  a bed of linguine. 

Peppercorn or Sesame Crusted Tuna ...................................26.99 

Your choice of crusted tuna pan seared to your liking  served over mashed potatoes and fine creamed spinach. 

Coconut Shrimp ........................................................................................24.99 

Big Mama’s secret blend of homemade coconut  breaded shrimp complimented with sweet dipping  sauce served over rice. 

Maryland Jumbo Lump  Crab Cakes ..................................22.99 

Homemade Blue Claw crab cakes sautéed in a scallion  sherry wine sauce. Served over rice with fresh vegetable.  

Lobster Marinara....................................................................................31.99 

“Our Signature Dish” Lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, & bay  scallops in a choice of homemade sweet, fra diavolo  or white sauce served over linguine. 

Cedar Plank Salmon...........................................................................26.99 

Fresh cut Atlantic Salmon baked on a cedar plank  board with a brown sugar glaze and served with a  side of homemade mashed potatoes. 

Wild Salmon - Add 4.99 

Fish Tacos....................................................................................................23.99 

Grilled codfish stuffed in soft tacos with lettuce, tomato,  onion, cheddar cheese, and salsa. Served with sour cream  and rice. 

Substitute shrimp 2.99, tuna 3.99  or Chilean sea bass 4.99 

Lobster Roll Dinner..............................................................................24.99 

Fresh lobster salad overflowing in a sweet toasted bun  with choice of fries, rice, baked potato or mashed potatoes. 

Caprese Tilapia......................................................................................22.99 

Grilled Tilapia layered with fresh homemade mozzarella  cheese, tomato and red onion. Drizzled with a homemade  balsamic reduction and served with a side of yellow rice. 

Lobster Mac & Cheese....................................................................27.99 

Fresh lobster meat in a creamy cheese sauce with macaroni. 

Shrimp Carbanaro..............................................................................24.99 

Shrimp covered in an alfredo sauce with bacon and peas over linguini.

Chilean Sea Bass..................................................................................26.99

Pan seared then baked in a sherry cream sauce with scallions and tomatoes. Served with rice.

LAND LOVERS AND SANDWHICHES

Land Lovers Menu 

Served with your choice of the soup of the day or  house salad 


10oz Flat Iron Steak ........................................................................22.99 

Grilled the way you want it, served in Mom’s homemade  delicious marinade. Baked potato and vegetable. 

Chicken Portafino...............................................................................21.99 

Parmesean-breaded, boneless breast, fried and  covered in a scallion, lemon sauce. Served over rice. 

Grilled Chicken and Broccoli....................................................21.99 

Sautéed in white garlic wine sauce served over linguine.

Chicken Parmigiana .......................................................................21.99 

Hand-breaded, deep-fried chicken covered in  marinara sauce and mozzarella, served over linguine. 

Linguine with Meatballs ..............................................................21.99 

Fresh meatballs with homemade marinara sauce over  linguine.  



Sandwiches 

Sandwiches served on a roll with lettuce, onion, tomato, tartar sauce,  and macaroni salad. Choice of fries, rice or baked potato. Add American,  cheddar, Swiss, mozzarella, feta, bacon or avocado $1.00 each. 


L.I. Flounder Sandwich ...................................................................15.99 

Hand cut and breaded flounder, fried and served on  a roll w/ lettuce, tomato and onion. Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich .............................................16.99 

Fresh Blue Claw Crab meat patty served with  lettuce, tomato, onion, remoulade sauce and  an onion ring on a roll. 

Old Bay Crab Cake Sandwich ..................................................13.99 

Homemade cakes formed to fit the roll then deep  fried with a hint of Old Bay Spice. 

Maryland Soft Shell Crab...............................................................Priced to Market 

Maryland Jumbo Soft Crab (seasonal) breaded and fried.  A tradition in our area.  

The Riley Burger.....................................................................................17.99 

8oz burger served with the works, just the way Riley likes it. Served on a roll with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato,  Onion, Cheese, Pickle, & Thousand Island Dressing. 

Chicken Sandwich................................................................................13.99 

Grilled, fried or blackened chicken served on a roll. 

Meatball or Chicken Parm Hoagie........................................13.99 

Served with homemade marinara sauce covered in  mozzarella cheese


loBSTER AND CRAB LEGS

Lobster and Crab Legs 

Served with soup of the day or house salad and baked potato 


1¼ pound Lobster Dinner..................................................................Market Price 

1½ pound Lobster Dinner..................................................................Market Price 

2 pound Lobster Dinner ...................................................................Market Price

Fill your lobster with our homemade seafood stuffing  for an extra 6.50, then we bake it to perfection. 

Brazilian #1 Lobster Tail Dinner 

6oz.....25.99 Twin.....40.99 

8oz.....31.99 Twin.....52.99 

10-12oz........38.99 Twin.....64.99 

16-20oz........52.99 Twin.....98.99 

Basted with butter and white wine, baked then broiled to  perfection.  

King Crab Leg Dinner.........................................................................Market Price 

1 pound of Alaska-caught King Crab Legs steamed  and served with drawn butter. 

Snow Crab Leg Dinner .....................................................................36.99 

1 pound of Alaskan Snow Crab legs steamed and served  with drawn butter. 

Surf & Turf....................................................................................................39.99 

#1 Brazilian 6oz LobsterTail served next to a marinaded 10oz  New York flat iron cooked just the way you like it and served  with baked potato & vegetable. 

Substitute 8oz tail 7.99 


Lobster Bake..............................................................................................44.99

1-1.25 lb North American Lobster, L. I. Clams, L. I. Steamers, Prince Edward Island Mussels, &corn on the cob or baked potato

Captain Seth's Amazing Barge...................................................120.00

1 Includes a 1.25 Lobster, 5 Clams, 5 Oysters, 1 lb King Crab Legs, 10 Jumbo Shrimp, Drawn Butter &Cocktail Sauce Served on a chilled ice barge.

sEAFOOD PASTA DISHES

Seafood Pasta Dishes 

Served with your choice of the soup of the day or house salad

Gluten free pasta $2.00 extra per order 


Red or White Clam Sauce.............................................................22.99 

Atlantic Ocean clams smothered in choice of homemade  red or white sauce, served over linguine. 

Mussels .........................................................................................................22.99 

Prince Edward Island mussels cooked in a garlic  wine or marinara sauce, served over linguine. Shrimp or Flounder Parmigiana..............................................24.99 

Deep fried and breaded, covered in marinara sauce  and mozzarella cheese, served over linguine. Linguine Shrimp Scampi .........................................22.99 

Pan-seared shrimp in a tasty garlic, oil and breadcrumb mix, served over linguine. 

Shellfish Marinara................................................................................26.99 

Shrimp, bay scallops, clams, and mussels, served in  your choice of red or white sauce over linguine.  

Shrimp and Scallops in Pink.......................................................24.99 

Sauteed shrimp and bay scallops covered in a creamy  pink sauce served over linguine. 

Crispy Calamari Delight ...............................................................22.99 

Long Island, tender calamari breaded and fried then covered  with marinara sauce and mozzarella, served over linguine


FRESH FROM THE COUNTER

Fresh from our Counter 

All dinners include mac salad, tartar sauce, & lemon.  Choice of fries, rice or baked potato. 


Fried Dinners 

Fish and Chips.....................................................................................14.99 

Clam Strips ............................................................................................13.99 

Calamari ..................................................................................................14.99 

Fish Cakes................................................................................................12.99 

Crab Cakes..............................................................................................13.99 

Oysters........................................................................................................17.99 

Boneless White Meat Chicken.................................................13.99 

Buffalo Shrimp.....................................................................................16.99 

Soft Shell Crab or Sauteed........................................................priced to market 

Flounder Fillet .....................................................................................15.99 

Stuffed Flounder with Seafood Stuffing .......................21.99 

Stuffed Flounder with Spinach and Feta Stuffing ......21.99 Codfish........................................................................................................15.99 

Haddock ...................................................................................................14.99 

Bay Scallops...........................................................................................15.99 

Sea Scallops...........................................................................................19.99 

Shrimp .......................................................................................................16.99 

Catfish........................................................................................................14.99 

Cajun Catfish.......................................................................................14.99 

“Hat Trick” .............................................................................................19.99 

Shrimp, Bay Scallops, & Flounder 

“Shellfish Medley”.............................................................................19.99 

Shrimp, Clam Strips, Bay Scallops 

“Fisherman’s Platter” ......................................................................20.99 

Shrimp, Oysters, Bay Scallops, Clam Strips, & Flounder 


Broiled or Grilled Dinners 

Flounder Fillet (Broiled Only) .............................................................................................17.99 

Stuffed Flounder with Seafood Stuffing (Broiled Only) ..............................21.99 

Stuffed Flounder with Spinach and Feta Stuffing (Broiled Only) .......21.99 Codfish....................................................................................................................................................16.99 

Bay Scallops (Broiled Only)..................................................................................................16.99 

Sea Scallops.......................................................................................................................................21.99 

Shrimp ....................................................................................................................................................16.99 

Catfish.....................................................................................................................................................15.99 

Cajun Catfish.....................................................................................................................................15.99 

Tuna..........................................................................................................................................................19.99 

Swordfish..............................................................................................................................................19.99 

Salmon...................................................................................................................................................18.99 

Wild Salmon ....................................................................................................................................23.99 

Stuffed Shrimp (Broiled Only)...........................................................................................17.99 

Shrimp Scampi...............................................................................................................................17.99 

Mahi-Mahi...........................................................................................................................................18.99 

Chilean Sea Bass..........................................................................................................................22.99 

Orange Roughy ...........................................................................................................................18.99 

Tilapia ..................................................................................................................................................15.99 

“Hat Trick”.........................................................................................................................................20.99 

Shrimp, Bay Scallops, & Flounder (Broiled Only) 


Walk around and check out our fresh fish case for any other favorite fish  for dinner tonight! 

Try one of our signature marinades All Broiled & Grilled dinners are cooked with butter, lemon, & white wine  or try one of our marinades or sauces - Lemon Butter Dill, House Marinade,  Mom’s Marinade, D’s Kickin Dippin Sauce, Remoulade Sauce, Ginger Teriyaki,  Cajun, Caribbean, Honey Horseradish Mustard or Blackening. $1.99 extra

sIDES

Sides 

Fries..........................................................................................................3.99 

Curly Fries............................................................................................3.99 

Sweet Potato Fries.......................................................................4.99 

Baked Potato ...................................................................................2.99 

Mashed Potatoes...........................................................................3.99 

Onion Rings........................................................................................4.99 

Yellow Rice...........................................................................................2.99 

Creamed Spinach & Feta ......................................................5.99 

Corn on the Cob (Seasonal).................................................2.99 

Fresh vegetable of the day .................................................5.99 

Linguine with marinara sauce ...........................................5.99 

Coleslaw ................................................................................................1.99 

Garlic Bread........................................................................................2.99 

Garden Salad ...................................................................................4.99 

Broccoli...................................................................................................5.99 

Onion Straws......................................................................................4.99 

Meatballs Marinara.......................................................................5.99 

kiDS mENU AND DRINKS

Kids Menu  $9.99 - Kids Dessert Included 

Hot Dog 

1 Grilled Sabrett Hot Dog served with fries 

Burger 

Grilled burger or cheeseburger served with fries 

Chicken Fingers  

Hand breaded chicken deep fried served with fries  

Grilled Cheese 

American cheese sandwich grilled and served with fries 

Fish Cakes 

Two cod-filled fish cakes deep fried and served with fries 

Clam Strips  

Breaded clam strips, fried and served with fries 

Flounder  

A delectable filet of Long Island flounder breaded and  fried. Served with fries 

Linguini Pasta 

Linguini pasta bowl offered with choice of marinara  sauce or butter 

Mac and Cheese 

Meagan & Avery’s favorite creamy cheesy covered spiral pasta 


Ice Cold 

Fountain Soda 

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Sierra  Mist, Iced Tea, Lemonade, Unsweetened Iced  Tea, Sparkling Water, Bottled Water,  Chocolate Milk, Pop’s Brooklyn Style Egg Cream Iced Coffee 

Root beer float 

Beer On Tap 

Blue Point Toasted Lager • Blue Point Seasonal • Blue Point Hoptical 

Ice Cold Beer by the Bottle 

Budweiser • Bud Light • Heineken • Heineken Light BP Toasted Lager • BP Hoptical • BP Seasonal  Michelob Ultra • O’Doul’s and other specialty beers 

White Wine 

Chardonnay, Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon Blanc 

Red Wine 

Merlot, Cabernet, Pinot Noir Blush  White Zinfandel 


Please Ask About our Desserts

Copyright © 2023 Seth Needelman - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by GoDaddy

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept