The Fish Store
 (631) 472-3018
836 Montauk Highway
Bayport New York, 11705


Market & Restaurant


Join us in our beautiful restaurant. Fresh cut fish cooked for you daily, Lobster Dinners, clams on the half shell, oysters on the half shell, and much much more.  We also served wine and local beer on tap including Blue Point Brewery Seasonal beers.
Check out our menu below.

Restaurant Menu

Enjoy some of our Fish Store Favorites

Lobster Marinara

Lobster Mac N' Cheese (Special of the Day)