THE FISH STORE

THE FISH STORETHE FISH STORETHE FISH STORE
  • Home/Contact Page
  • Upcoming/Current Events
  • Menus
    • Restaurant Lunch
    • Sushi
    • Catering
    • Seasonal Specials
  • Takeout
    • Lunch Takeout
    • Dinner Takeout
    • Fresh Fish
    • Platters/Bakes
  • Group Tours/Other Service
  • Looking for employment
  • Restaurant
  • Coupons
  • Apparel
  • Gallery
  • More
    • Home/Contact Page
    • Upcoming/Current Events
    • Menus
      • Restaurant Lunch
      • Sushi
      • Catering
      • Seasonal Specials
    • Takeout
      • Lunch Takeout
      • Dinner Takeout
      • Fresh Fish
      • Platters/Bakes
    • Group Tours/Other Service
    • Looking for employment
    • Restaurant
    • Coupons
    • Apparel
    • Gallery

THE FISH STORE

THE FISH STORETHE FISH STORETHE FISH STORE
  • Home/Contact Page
  • Upcoming/Current Events
  • Menus
    • Restaurant Lunch
    • Sushi
    • Catering
    • Seasonal Specials
  • Takeout
    • Lunch Takeout
    • Dinner Takeout
    • Fresh Fish
    • Platters/Bakes
  • Group Tours/Other Service
  • Looking for employment
  • Restaurant
  • Coupons
  • Apparel
  • Gallery

Located at 836 Montauk Highway Bayport 11705

Located at 836 Montauk Highway Bayport 11705Located at 836 Montauk Highway Bayport 11705Located at 836 Montauk Highway Bayport 11705
(631) 472-3018

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

Fresh Seafood | Sushi Made Fresh | TAkeout | Dine-in | Catering experts | fish, Lobster & More

OUR FAVORITES

Wild Caught Seafood

Our seafood is always fresh and never frozen. We offer a wide variety of fish, including salmon, halibut, and cod, as well as shellfish like shrimp and scallops.

View Menus

Ready to order?

Call:

(631) 472-3018

Order Now on Doordash




About Our Fish and Market

A Local Tradition

The Fish Store is a family-owned restaurant and market located in the heart of Bayport.


We're proud to serve our community with the freshest seafood, friendly service, and memorable meals.

Private Events

Private Events

Private Events

From birthdays, to corporate events, private, we do it all.

Events

Catering

Private Events

Private Events

Custom menus for any occasion. We bring the freshness to you.

Catering Menu

Gallery

Private Events

Gallery

Take a look at our food, events & happy customers.

Photos

12 Years in a Row

Proud Winners of Bethpage Best of Long Island #1 Best Fish Market on Long Island since 2014.  Thank you to all our valued customers, we appreciate you. 


Thank you for voting us Best Fish Market 12 years in a row!





Check Out Some of Our Current & Up Coming Events

What's in this season?

Join Our Mailing List

Stay updated on current events, fresh catch of the day,  specials, and more by joining our mailing list!!

Either click link below or scan our QR code above.


https://forms.gle/cMhtFmBE5zyPn6db9



We'll Text You

Want to receive great offers, specials, and news to your phone?


TEXT "YES" to (844)986-4500 

and you're all set!


About Us

Our History

Through our commitment, experience, and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime!

Find New Products

The Fish Store provides top-notch Fresh Fish, Live Lobsters, Dinners To Go, Catering and more, along with great customer service - a combination that can't be beat!

Contact Us

Drop us a line!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

The Fish Store

836 MONTAUK HIGHWAY BAYPORT 11705

(631) 472-3018

Hours

Open today

09:00 am – 08:00 pm

Social

Copyright © 2026 Seth Needelman - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept