OUR FAVORITES
Premium Quality Meats
Premium Quality Meats
Premium Quality Meats
Our meat is sourced from trusted local farmers and we personally inspect each cut to ensure the highest quality. Choose from beef, pork, lamb, and more.
Wild Caught Seafood
Premium Quality Meats
Premium Quality Meats
Our seafood is always fresh and never frozen. We offer a wide variety of fish, including salmon, halibut, and cod, as well as shellfish like shrimp and scallops.
Custom Meat Cutting
Premium Quality Meats
Custom Meat Cutting
Need a specific cut of meat for a recipe? Our expert butchers can custom cut any meat to your specifications. Just ask and we'll be happy to help.
Private Events
Private Events
Private Events
From birthdays, to corporate events, private, we do it all.
Catering
Private Events
Private Events
Custom menus for any occasion. We bring the freshness to you.
12 Years in a Row
Proud Winners of Bethpage Best of Long Island #1 Best Fish Market on Long Island since 2014. Thank you to all our valued customers, we appreciate you.
We are excited to be nominated for the Best Fish Market on all Long Island for the 13th year in a row!
We would love you to please vote for us again. Voting can be done every day from today until December 15th, 2025. Thank you.
www.bestoflongisland.com
Look for the “Food” category
Then click on “Fish Market” category
Then click “The Fish Store - Bayport”.
Check Out Some of Our Current & Up Coming Events
Join Our Mailing List
Stay updated on current events, fresh catch of the day, specials, and more by joining our mailing list!!
Either click link below or scan our QR code above.
https://forms.gle/cMhtFmBE5zyPn6db9
We'll Text You
Want to receive great offers, specials, and news to your phone?
TEXT "YES" to (844)986-4500
and you're all set!